Miles Franklin 2011: the short shortlist

Just in. The books shortlisted for the 2011 Miles Franklin Literary Award are:

Bereft by Chris Womersley
That Deadman Dance by Kim Scott
When Colts Ran by Roger McDonald

Of course, the comment has begun (on Twitter) about the fact that there are only three books. Martin Shaw says (@thebooksdesk) ‘A shortlist of 3 becomes a bit of a damning take on the longlist to me – as if the other 6 were just chosen for some local colour!’ I wasn’t at the announcement and the press release hasn’t found it’s way into my inbox yet but Jennifer Byrne from the First Tuesday Book Club (@tuesdaybookclub) tweeted that the judges said, regarding the shortlist of three, ‘they had read lots of books that were not ready for publication and lacked great editing…’ She also reported that the judges said ‘Australian voice’ was the most striking feature of the books nominated.

And of course, they’re all dudes (as in 2009). Roger McDonald and Kim Scott are also former winners.

I haven’t read all three of these, but I’m sure they’re good, quality reads. Chris Womersley’s Bereft certainly is, and I’ll put my money on that. I’m keen to read That Deadman Dance too. But isn’t it striking that Australian life, according to the Miles Franklin judges, is still represented by the past and the outback, and is written in a male voice. Sheep stations, war, colonisation. Like I said, I’m sure the books are good, but I feel the award continues to narrowly define ‘Australian life’ – and the longlist certainly does feel a bit like a cop out. When you look at the final three you feel like those other books never had a chance.

Comments?

I’m sorry this is rough, wanted to get it out quick. I’ll update with some official comments from the judges or links later.

UPDATE

The official comments are up on the Trust website now. See here. The judges say: ‘These shortlisted books have a distinctive, indelible Australian voice. It’s a voice that has nothing to do with reflex nationalism, or jingoism – rather the reverse. The shortlisted books this year are like barometers of the state of our culture: they take the readings, and give them back to us in fiction of extraordinary accomplishment. They force us to look again at ourselves, and to think – hard.’

And here’s some comments on the individual novels:

On Bereft: ‘This is a beautifully written book, spare and compelling. The tragedy and bleakness of the story are, at times, almost unbearable but Womersley’s fine prose and narrative intensity make Bereft unforgettable.’

On That Deadman Dance: ‘That Deadman Dance is alive in the spaces between these two worlds as they collide and collaborate. It tells the story of the rapid destruction of Noongar people and their traditions. At the same time, there is the enchanting possibility of the birth of a new world in the strange song, dance, ceremony and language that are produced by these encounters of very different peoples.’

On When Colts Ran: ‘When Colts Ran, with its cavalcade of flawed, rough cut Australian characters, illustrates poignantly the way the optimism and confidence of rural Australia in the middle of the twentieth century slipped away and how family experience, class and social expectation shaped communities. Roger McDonald evokes that world with an inwardness and poetic verve that is extraordinary.’

11 thoughts on “Miles Franklin 2011: the short shortlist

  1. I really agree with you on how problematic it is that Australian literature seems to be defined as male, and very Australiana – which is always what turned me off reading Australian literature and made me search out for other stuff. I like the migrant voice, the female voice, even the anti-Australiana voice that doesn’t glorify the nation, just tells it as it is.

    Also wishing there was more genre, but that’s a problem with awards worldwide, that genre novels seem to only win genre awards

  2. Genre doesn’t really suit the MF as it must be a ‘published novel or play portraying Australian life in any of its phases’ according to Miles Franklin’s will. So anything fantastical or set in the future would be difficult to justify under these terms.

    But while we’re broadly commenting on the Miles Franklin judges’ definition of ‘Australian life’, it should be noted that Kim Scott is an Indigenous author, and that Chris Womersley’s Bereft (the only one I can comment on as I’ve read it) does not in any way ‘glorify the nation’. In fact, it’s a moody, gothic story which feels as though it is more influenced by murder ballad songs, than any ‘Australiana’-type fiction.

    It’s just very interesting to compare the shortlisted books to the longlisted ones and wonder if the separation was purely about quality.

  3. Pingback: Miles Franklin Brouhaha |

  4. Pingback: jennifer mills – blog › another story from the bush

  5. Pingback: Miles Franklin shortlist « Fancy Goods

  6. Pingback: Past winners make Miles Franklin shortlist – ABC Online | newzbuff.com

  7. Pingback: The Australian Voice in Fiction: What is it? What should it be? « Bite The Book – Book Reviews and Industry Views

  8. When the longlist was released, I did what I usually do: I tried to get copies of each, locally. For the last three or so years, it has been getting harder and harder. Readings.com is brilliant, but for me walking through a bookshop holds a deeper connection. Sadly, plenty of Dan Brown novels, a lack of ‘Australian’ novels (and what a vague and exclusive term that is). Is the Miles Franklin relevant? It is an act of exclusion, much like Australian history? I see something like the Children’s Book Council awards for older readers as much more inclusive, a celebration of the written word.

  9. Pingback: Is it a man’s world, literally? – ABC Online | newzbuff.com

  10. Pingback: When Colts Ran, by Roger McDonald « ANZ LitLovers LitBlog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s